Why this works
At first glance, this riddle seems to leave us in the dark, but it cleverly plays with our expectations about the concept of "breaking." The phrase "breaks but never falls" refers to the transition of night into day — when dawn "breaks," the darkness of night recedes, signaling the start of a new day. This wordplay hinges on the dual meaning of "break," which can imply both a physical shattering and a metaphorical shift, as in the break of dawn.
Delving deeper, the imagery of dawn evokes a sense of renewal and hope, which resonates across cultures and time. The term "dawn" itself derives from the Old English word "dæge," signifying the light that heralds a new beginning. This riddle is clever because it invites us to step back from our literal interpretations and embrace the poetic nature of language. The "aha moment" strikes when we realize that dawn, while a time of day, does not conform to the physical attributes of something that can "fall."
As a delightful bonus, many cultures celebrate dawn as a symbol of rebirth and enlightenment, evident in various mythologies and literature. For instance, in ancient Greece, the goddess Eos personified the dawn, bringing light and new possibilities. So, next time you marvel at a sunrise, remember the riddle that reminds us of the beauty and significance of this daily transformation!