In a closely contested race, the judges call for a photo finish to determine the winner. It becomes clear that Alfonso crossed the line in first place, just ahead of Samuel. None of the judges dispute this, and yet they award the trophy to Frankie, who crossed the line in third place. Alfonso and Samuel have not broken the rules or done anything that might prejudice the judges against them. So why does Frankie receive the trophy?

“Frankie cheated by pushing Alfonso and Samuel out of the way.”

There is no indication in the riddle that any rules were broken or that cheating occurred, and the judges did not dispute the results.

“Frankie was the fastest runner overall, regardless of when he crossed the finish line.”

The race results are based on the order of crossing the finish line, and the riddle specifically states that Frankie finished third.

“Frankie was the judge's favorite, so they decided to give him the trophy.”

The riddle makes it clear that the judges did not dispute the results and that Frankie received the trophy for a legitimate reason related to Alfonso.